In the aftermath of all that, the group was certainly exhausted. Rather than let Isolda spent the night in her cramped starfighter, Starlin offered her shelter aboard the Bright Knight. She accepted, more for the promise of a hot meal than anything else. For his part Starlin was glad to put off the inevitable epilogue when everyone would go their separate ways. He wanted to keep Isolda close for a little while longer.
Physically tired but mentally wide awake, he never went to bed. After bidding Kyla and Lara good night, he remained seated at the table in the rec room with his datapad in front of him. He was in the middle of the second paragraph of his mission report when Isolda appeared from the hallway, wearing plain gray pajamas.
"Hello," she greeted him shyly. "I can't sleep."
"Me neither," he said. "Can I get you anything?"
She hesitated, then answered, "A glass of water would be nice."
Standing up, Starlin grabbed a cup from a cabinet, placed it inside the drink dispenser and pressed the button. While the water poured, he tried to figure out what to say. He wanted to talk to her very badly, but he didn't know where to start. Finally, he said, "Y'know, apart from killing all those cultists, it kinda feels like we didn't really do much on Chaldea."
"We sent all those cultists to hell," she said. "Besides, we were without the Force for half the time. Loath as I am to admit it, I rely on the Ashla a great deal."
"True. But Kai's the one who defeated their leader, and then he sacrificed himself to save the planet. Compared to that, we did jack shit."
"Is this a debate about who contributed the most, or are you just beating yourself up because you couldn't save Kai?" she asked.
"I--" Starlin began, then faltered, his shoulders sagging. The dispenser chimed. "Forget it," he mumbled, passing the full cup to her.
Isolda nodded in understanding, accepted the water and took a sip. "He's at least deserving of a mention in your report."
"I dunno how well a Sithspawn saving the day would go over with the Jedi Masters." Starlin glanced up at Isolda as a new thought occurred to him. "Did you know that Kai was a Sithspawn?" She wouldn't have been able to sense his aura, being deprived of the Force.
"I believe he mentioned it, yes."
"And did that fact not... bother you, at all?" By all accounts, it should have been a non-negotiable for her. The Ashlan Crusaders were known to be so harsh in their judgment of Dark Siders that they crucified anyone remotely connected to the Sith. The Isolda he knew was no different. It was one of the reasons why they couldn't be together. No amount of attraction could cover up the fact that she was intolerant even of those whose circumstances were beyond their control.
"He saved the lives of your students and killed the Witch," Isolda replied. "Though his flesh was damned, he proved by his actions that his spirit walked with Ashla."
"So it didn't bother you." Starlin stared at her in wonderment. "What changed?"
She seemed to grow tense under his scrutiny, putting her cup down on the island countertop. "He also spoke of his dark past, as I recall. You knew him then, did you not? Did his behavior not bother you?"
"I knew him when he was at his lowest point. He went to Azrael for his mistakes."
"Mistakes?" Her eyes narrowed. "I wouldn't call choosing to stay in a Sithspawn body a mistake. That's your problem, Starlin - you're too loyal to people. You make excuses for them even when they do unforgivable things. It was the same way with your old master, that fire witch--"
Starlin bristled at her words, but found that he had no will to argue. As he stood there in silence, Isolda seemed to run out of steam, breaking off when he failed to respond. "Why... Why aren't you fighting back?" she asked.
"Why should I?" he asked, smiling faintly. "Everything you say about me is true. I am loyal to a fault."
Her lower lip quivered, ready to respond with a sharp retort to a snarky comeback that never came. Her expression crumpled, and for a moment she looked like she was on the verge of tears. "I'm sorry, Starlin."
"It's okay," he said. "At least you put your faith in a perfect deity rather than flawed people. I wish I could do the same. But I'm too weak. I could never fight for a cause I believed in. But a pathetic, miserable, screwed up person? I get that. I'm the same way. I'm no good."
"You're not weak," Isolda said. "And you're not no good. You're human, and so am I."
The steel conviction in her voice sent a shiver down his spine. He almost couldn't believe what he was hearing. Starlin was self-deprecating by nature, but Isolda of Ession? She had always been proud. Yet here she was, showing humility and self-awareness for the first time since he had met her.
"You think my faith in the Ashla is perfect? You think I don't ever have doubts?" she continued, standing strong even as tears began to fill her eyes. "The ideals I was taught didn't stand up against the realities I faced out in the galaxy. I was supposed to scorn you for not converting, Starlin, but I loved you. I still love you."
He started to reach for her, slow and cautious. But she practically threw herself into his arms, holding him tight as she buried her face in his neck.
"Why did we do this to ourselves, Isolda?" he whispered. "Hold ourselves to these impossible standards. Why isn't it enough that we love each other?"
"I don't know anymore. We must not have known any better." She pulled back. “Let's not make the same mistake again. I will forgive you, if you will forgive me.”
It was like the embers of a dying fire were rekindled in him. Starlin let out a breath he hadn't realized he'd been holding. "I forgive you," he said, then whispered. "I love you."
It was hard to tell who kissed who first. He only knew that her lips were soft and her breath was hot as she eagerly opened her mouth against his, hungry for what they had denied themselves for so many years. It was Starlin who broke the kiss at last, pressing his cheek to her brow as he caught his breath. "Are you sure this is what you want?" he gasped, terrified and exhilarated and wanting more than anything to hear her say it.
"Starlin Rand, I wish to marry you," she replied, her voice husky and irresistible. "Will you accept my offer?"
His panting gave way to giddy laughter. "Holy shit..." He stroked her long hair, grinning from ear to ear as he gazed lovingly into her eyes. "Yeah. Let's get married." Before he could second-guess himself, he kissed her again.