[member="Kalyn Shif"]
Ms Lobster, it’s been a pretty wild 5 years, that’s for sure!
On a writer level you’re a lovely person, very nice, easy to talk to, willing to help. I have had no complaints about you personally as far as I can recall, and you’ve always done your best to assist people.
However, since you are asking for feedback I will attempt to be constructive here. The usual caveats apply here that this is just my opinion.
My first point is that because your RL has been rather uncertain at times it means that you are very frequently away on LOA. That’s not your fault, but it does make creating a long time writing partnership or doing threads can be tricky. I know I’ve had several cases where we’ve started a thread, you’ve had something come up and by the time you return it’s not possible to continue.
My second is that your characters seem (at least the ones I’ve seen/interacted with) to be pretty similar. A lot of them rotate between names but seem to be very similar with personalities so it’s hard for me to get a handle on which is which. Further, I feel that your characters tend to be rather ‘mild’, even the ones which are supposed to be evil seem to preserve some of your inherent niceness which undermines their evil schemes.
Technically your writing is good and I have no complaints about the clarity of your prose.
Finally, I’d say that you have the record right now for the most profile name changes for a writer – think you passed the previous record holder at some stage this year. So that’s an achievement!
Either on me personally, or the characters I have/have had
