New Map Discrepancies

[Valiens Nantaris]

In light of the new map there are some planets which have moved places for whatever reason.

Please post any discrepancies here using the following template.

Planet Name: (Link name to Wookieepedia article)
Current Location: (Describe or screenshot)
Suggested Location: (Describe or screenshot)
Reasoning: (Please provide evidence or reasoning why it should be changed.)

NOTE:

• This is only for planets currently on the map. More are being added daily, and custom planets will begin being added once canon planets are set.
• Currently we are only putting one planet per hex, requests involving multiple planets per hex will not be considered until we finish the first pass.
• This is only for planets/moons. Other phenomena such as stations are not being added yet.
• This thread is NOT for off topic or arguments. Please PM an Admin if you have concerns.
• Site admins will review the posts in this thread and decide on whether or not to implement the request.
• Do not tag any specific staff member.

 

[Darth Carnifex]

Planet Name: Chandrila
Current Location: Click
Suggested Location: Click
Reasoning:

• Screenshot of the Star Wars Interactive Galaxy Map
• Bormea Sector

 

[Darth Carnifex]

Planet Name: Corulag
Current Location: Click
Suggested Location: Click
Reasoning:

• Screenshot of the Star Wars Interactive Galaxy Map
• Bormea Sector

 

[Kuzo]

[member="Darth Carnifex"]

Reviewed and addressed. Thank you!

 

[Skorvek]

Planet Name: Mandalore
Current Location: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/375838085755437069/553320968127381515/2019-03-07_14_59_38-Chaos_Galaxy_Map.png
Suggested Location: Put in the same Hex as Oyar'u while moving Oyar'u to Mandalores hex
Reasoning: As shown in the Old Map: https://i.gyazo.com/eef93007ba1b1b332a25230c377091ac.pngMandalore, if it is in the hex it is on the new map, would have been located in a 4 Planet hex, which did not exist on the old map. Therefore Mandalore should be in the Hex with Oya'ru, however due to the New Map rules, there is a 2 planet maximum. I propose that Mandalore be moved to a hex that is historically accurate to the Old Map and switch places with the custom planet Oya'ru in order to at least have one planet in the Hex that Mandalore is located in at the current - Or to add in one of the other Planets listed in the screenshot of the Old Map.
https://i.gyazo.com/4848837c4be5d6b8fd0af32db6121111.png

 

[Darth Carnifex]

Planet Name: Nathema
Current Location: Click
Suggested Location: Click
Reasoning:

• Screenshot of the Chorlian Sector

 

[Darth Carnifex]

Planet Name: Troiken
Current Location: Click
Suggested Location: Click
Reasoning:

• Screenshot of the Colundra Sector

 

[Skorvek]

Planet Name: Anobis
Current Location: hex y-23
Suggested Location: Here
Reasoning: Anobis isn't on the map anymore despite ME has been domming the planet since February (with some distractions due to invasion.) As such, we propose moving it to Qiilura as that is a planet that ME dommed a few months ago (which made last months dom kind of useless.)

 

[Matt the Radar Tech]

Planet Name: Rhigar
Current Location: Image
Suggested Location: Image
Reasoning:

• To align planets based on Star Wars Essential Atlas more accurately.
• To make room for new canon planet locations between planets already on the map (where not enough room remains for additional planet placement currently).

 

[Matt the Radar Tech]

Planet Name: Kinoss
Current Location: Image
Suggested Location: Image
Reasoning:

• To align planets based on Star Wars Essential Atlas more accurately.
• To make room for new canon planet locations between planets already on the map (where not enough room remains for additional planet placement currently).

 

[Matt the Radar Tech]

Planet Name: The Redoubt
Current Location: Image
Suggested Location: Image
Reasoning:

• To separate two important locations from a single hex (Ilum and Redoubt).
• To provide another dominion opportunity for CA, in another hex.
• To more accurately represent the distance from Chiss Space, Ilum and the Redoubt based on SW Interactive Galaxy Map.

 

[Kuzo]

[member="Skorvek"]

Mandalore- We won't be using 'because it was like the old map' as a sufficient reason to move a planet. We have added Concordia (much like Nar Shaddaa and Trandosha in their respective hexes) to put another planet in the Mandalore hex for the moment. Other planets in the area will be assessed as we keep working. Keep in mind that even if a planet is not on the map does not mean that it is not there- both canon and chaos canon worlds still exist, the map is to highlight the most important ones in an area, so any planets you had you still control if they were in your sphere before but do not appear on the map now!

Anobis - Good planet with good wiki info, no issue adding it to the map and your placement is accurate to the galactic map. Added.

[member="Darth Carnifex"]

Nathema- This is a very close and we won't be moving Nathema just a single hex when it's in relative position. The screen shot does show how off Malachor is however so we are fixing that.
Trokien- Definitely in the wrong position, but the canon map shows above that hyperlane so we've fixed it based on that.

[member="Thorne"]
Rhigar, Kinoss - In canon, Chiss space is really bunched up compared to the rest of the galaxy. But there's also not a lot else to put up there instead. In a more crowded area of space we'd need to decline but there is some room to spread out here and get a few more planets added. These moves are within reason and granted.

The Redoubt- That location was already moved to the neighboring hex on a previous tweak, so you're good to go.

 

[Darth Carnifex]

Planet Name: Ord Janon
Current Location: Click
Suggested Location: Click
Reasoning:

• Map of the Yuuzhan Vong's attack
• Star Wars Galaxy Map Snap Of The Area
• From my estimations, this would place Ord Janon further behind Xo on the map
  I've made two canon planet requests to better visualize this

 

[Kuzo]

[member="Darth Carnifex"]

While normally I'm not going to move a planet a single hex, there is room in that area to spread out, rather than double up with the additions of the new planets. No objections and done.

 

[Kuzo]

With the planets no longer getting moved around, this is getting archived. Address issues, additions, etc to the map update thread.