Seren Gwyn
White Star
Seren listened to the apparition's explanation with increasing unease, her amber eyes following its slow movements through the graveyard. The description of the Netherborn was considerably more disturbing than she had anticipated, particularly the suggestion that a host might remain conscious while something else commandeered their body and systematically destroyed everything they cherished. She had encountered enough accounts of possession during her studies to understand that such a fate was possible, but hearing the prospect described with such evident satisfaction made the distinction between scholarly curiosity and personal recklessness rather apparent. The creature's skeletal fingers passed uncomfortably close, and although she resisted the instinct to retreat, her expression cooled considerably.
"You make a compelling argument against inviting one of your kind into my body," she observed, her voice retaining its customary composure despite the revulsion beneath it. "I appreciate the explanation, although I suspect you intended it to be rather more persuasive than reassuring." There was little point in pretending she had not been intrigued by the possibilities. She still was, to a degree, but the prospect of gaining knowledge or power hardly justified surrendering her autonomy to a creature that regarded another person's suffering as nourishment. Whatever questions she continued to ask about her own identity, she had no intention of allowing something else to answer them on her behalf.
Nemesis's observations drew her attention away from the circling apparition. She considered the distinction he described, gradually recognizing why Jerek's initial request had seemed different from those of the other spirits. Rebirth was not merely a means of escaping the Netherworld. It was an opportunity to assume an existence that had once belonged to someone else, complete with their appearance, memories, and desires. That realization troubled her in ways the prospect of possession had not. The creature might genuinely become the person it imitated in every observable respect, yet the individual whose life had ended would remain beyond its reach. What returned would be something new, wearing the familiar face of the dead.
For a moment, Seren said nothing. She thought of Alderaan, of the family she had left behind, and of how little she knew about the lives they had led in her absence. Her older brother would have inherited responsibilities she had never particularly envied, while Dante was only fifteen, young enough that much of what he knew of her probably came from stories rather than memories. There were people she had lost during her years among the Jedi and Sith, certainly, but loss alone did not persuade her that she possessed the right to recreate them. She wondered whether someone who mourned deeply enough might convince themselves that the distinction between a returned loved one and a perfect imitation no longer mattered.
"I understand the appeal," she admitted at last, looking toward Nemesis before returning her attention to Jerek. "To see someone you've lost, hear their voice, perhaps even recover memories that disappeared with them. I imagine there are people who would sacrifice almost anything for such an opportunity." Her expression grew more contemplative. "But the person they mourned would still be dead. Whatever emerged would possess their memories and their likeness, yet it would be another consciousness living a life that wasn't originally its own."
The distinction was not necessarily an argument against the creature's existence. Seren had spent too many years examining the nature of consciousness to dismiss the possibility that something born through such a process could develop an identity deserving of recognition. What concerned her was the expectation that grief should provide the foundation for that identity, and that the living should sustain it through a bond whose obligations remained uncertain.
"And what happens when the person who summoned you begins to recognize the difference?" she asked Jerek. "You would remember being someone they loved, perhaps even feel the affection that person once felt. But you would also be yourself, whatever that eventually means. Would you be free to become someone different, or would the bond require you to remain the person they wanted back?"
She folded her hands before her, unwilling to offer a name merely to satisfy her curiosity. "I have no desire to condemn someone to an existence built entirely around another person's grief. Nor would I knowingly offer a grieving family an imitation and encourage them to believe death had been undone." Her gaze remained steady upon the apparition. "That doesn't mean I believe your desire for life is without merit, Jerek. But before I considered helping you achieve it, I would need to know whether there is a way for you to live as yourself rather than as someone else's replacement."
The question interested her for reasons extending beyond the immediate encounter. She had spent years attempting to distinguish the person she was from the identities others had bestowed upon her. It seemed a peculiar contradiction to defend that freedom in herself while denying it to a being seeking its first opportunity to experience the living world. Yet she was equally unwilling to mistake compassion for permission to meddle carelessly with the dead. For now, she would listen, and perhaps learn something neither the Jedi nor Sith had ever adequately explained.
Tobias Dib
"You make a compelling argument against inviting one of your kind into my body," she observed, her voice retaining its customary composure despite the revulsion beneath it. "I appreciate the explanation, although I suspect you intended it to be rather more persuasive than reassuring." There was little point in pretending she had not been intrigued by the possibilities. She still was, to a degree, but the prospect of gaining knowledge or power hardly justified surrendering her autonomy to a creature that regarded another person's suffering as nourishment. Whatever questions she continued to ask about her own identity, she had no intention of allowing something else to answer them on her behalf.
Nemesis's observations drew her attention away from the circling apparition. She considered the distinction he described, gradually recognizing why Jerek's initial request had seemed different from those of the other spirits. Rebirth was not merely a means of escaping the Netherworld. It was an opportunity to assume an existence that had once belonged to someone else, complete with their appearance, memories, and desires. That realization troubled her in ways the prospect of possession had not. The creature might genuinely become the person it imitated in every observable respect, yet the individual whose life had ended would remain beyond its reach. What returned would be something new, wearing the familiar face of the dead.
For a moment, Seren said nothing. She thought of Alderaan, of the family she had left behind, and of how little she knew about the lives they had led in her absence. Her older brother would have inherited responsibilities she had never particularly envied, while Dante was only fifteen, young enough that much of what he knew of her probably came from stories rather than memories. There were people she had lost during her years among the Jedi and Sith, certainly, but loss alone did not persuade her that she possessed the right to recreate them. She wondered whether someone who mourned deeply enough might convince themselves that the distinction between a returned loved one and a perfect imitation no longer mattered.
"I understand the appeal," she admitted at last, looking toward Nemesis before returning her attention to Jerek. "To see someone you've lost, hear their voice, perhaps even recover memories that disappeared with them. I imagine there are people who would sacrifice almost anything for such an opportunity." Her expression grew more contemplative. "But the person they mourned would still be dead. Whatever emerged would possess their memories and their likeness, yet it would be another consciousness living a life that wasn't originally its own."
The distinction was not necessarily an argument against the creature's existence. Seren had spent too many years examining the nature of consciousness to dismiss the possibility that something born through such a process could develop an identity deserving of recognition. What concerned her was the expectation that grief should provide the foundation for that identity, and that the living should sustain it through a bond whose obligations remained uncertain.
"And what happens when the person who summoned you begins to recognize the difference?" she asked Jerek. "You would remember being someone they loved, perhaps even feel the affection that person once felt. But you would also be yourself, whatever that eventually means. Would you be free to become someone different, or would the bond require you to remain the person they wanted back?"
She folded her hands before her, unwilling to offer a name merely to satisfy her curiosity. "I have no desire to condemn someone to an existence built entirely around another person's grief. Nor would I knowingly offer a grieving family an imitation and encourage them to believe death had been undone." Her gaze remained steady upon the apparition. "That doesn't mean I believe your desire for life is without merit, Jerek. But before I considered helping you achieve it, I would need to know whether there is a way for you to live as yourself rather than as someone else's replacement."
The question interested her for reasons extending beyond the immediate encounter. She had spent years attempting to distinguish the person she was from the identities others had bestowed upon her. It seemed a peculiar contradiction to defend that freedom in herself while denying it to a being seeking its first opportunity to experience the living world. Yet she was equally unwilling to mistake compassion for permission to meddle carelessly with the dead. For now, she would listen, and perhaps learn something neither the Jedi nor Sith had ever adequately explained.